Red Dead Redemption 2 features numerous optional errands given by gang members at the Van der Linde camp, adding depth to Arthur Morgan's relationships. One of the earliest requests comes from young Jack Marston, who asks Arthur to locate a cheap adventure novel known as a Penny Dreadful. Finding one of these books allows players to complete Jack's item request and earn a unique reward at camp.
Understanding Jack's Item Request
In Chapter 2 or Chapter 3, speaking with Jack at camp can trigger a special conversation where he asks for a comic book. Jack is interested in exciting pulp stories about wild heroes, which are categorized in the game world as Penny Dreadfuls. Fulfilling this request helps build the bond between Arthur and the camp members while contributing toward full completion.
There are multiple comic books scattered across the map, but you only need to return one to satisfy Jack's prompt. Finding a single copy in the wild will immediately update your quest log, allowing you to hand it over next time you rest at camp.
Finding the Book in Pleasance
One of the easiest places to retrieve a Penny Dreadful is in the abandoned settlement of Pleasance, located in the Lemoyne region. Head directly west of the swampy bayou area to discover the quiet ruins of this former township. Search inside the schoolhouse building located near the northern edge of the abandoned town site.
Inside the schoolhouse, look for a wooden desk situated near the front of the classroom. The comic book titled "Otis Miller and the Boy from New York" rests on top of the desk. Pick up the item to add it to Arthur's satchel for safe keeping.
Alternative Book Locations in the Wild
If you have already explored Lemoyne, another convenient location is Clawson's Rest, a small wooden cabin positioned north of Valentine. Search inside the homestead to locate a comic book lying on a nightstand beside a bed. This spot is ideal for players who prefer staying closer to the early game territories of New Hanover.
Another option is found at Downes Ranch, located southwest of Valentine. You can find a book inside the main farmhouse sitting on a nightstand in the bedroom. Visiting any of these locations ensures you pick up a valid copy for Jack without unnecessary backtracking.
Rewards for Returning the Book
Once you acquire any Penny Dreadful, return to the Van der Linde camp and locate Jack. Interact with him to trigger a short dialogue exchange where Arthur hands over the requested reading material. Jack will express his gratitude and leave a gift at Arthur's tent shortly after.
Your reward for completing this errand is a chocolate bar along with a piece of useful crafting material. Completing these small requests enriches the narrative immersion of the game while rewarding attentive exploration across the frontier.